Skip to content
Join our Newsletter

Canada calls itself a climate leader at COP31, experts disagree

Canada ranked 61 out of 76 countries in the 2026 Climate Change Performance Index, receiving a “very low” rating for emissions, renewable energy and energy use. 
environment-minister-emission
Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin did not address Canada's growing emissions at the UN's COP31.

Sierra Robinson grew up swimming in the rivers near her family’s farm on Vancouver Island. Now, she watches those same rivers run dry each summer. As water levels drop and farmers’ wells run low, her family now decides whether scarce water should go to crops or animals. 

Now 24, Robinson is one of 15 young Canadians bringing La Rose v. His Majesty the King, a constitutional challenge arguing that the federal government’s failure to adequately address climate change violates their Charter rights to life, liberty and security. Robinson said the plaintiffs are asking the federal court to require the government to create and implement a “science-based climate recovery plan.”

As world leaders gather in Antalya, Türkiye for the United Nations climate conference, she worries the decisions being made will shape what the future generations inherits. 

“We’re going to be feeling the impacts of the policies and decisions that are being made today,” Robinson said.  

Those decisions are at the centre of the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31), underway from Nov. 9 to 20. According to UN conference coverage, representatives from nearly 200 countries are negotiating how to cut emissions, finance climate action, make AI more sustainable and make final agreements about fossil fuels. 

On Wednesday, the UN launched the second global stocktake to take place in 2028, a process to assess how much progress countries have made under the Paris Agreement and what needs to happen next. 

Canada is using the conference to promote its work on methane reduction, clean energy and international climate financing. Environmental Minister Julie Dabrusin announced $116 million in new climate funding, and that Canada will chair the Global Methane Initiative to internationally reduce methane emissions and promote discussions on ocean sustainability. 

In an emailed statement to HumberETC, Environment and Climate Change Canada spokesperson Samantha Bayard said, “Canada is demonstrating that reducing emissions, strengthening resilience, attracting investment, and creating good jobs are mutually reinforcing objectives.”

At a press conference in February, Prime Minister Mark Carney said he considers, “Canada a leader in climate change and on focusing on climate change results and solutions.” 

But Canada’s record at home raises questions about how far that progress has gone. 

Carney did not attend COP31’s leaders’ summit, and Canada’s oil production has continued to climb. At COP31 on Wednesday, Canada issued a statement acknowledging that exceeding 1.5 C of warming is “widely seen as unavoidable.”

The Canadian Climate Institute estimates that emissions rose by about one per cent in 2025, reaching 691 megatonnes of greenhouse gases. Five years before its 2030 target, Canada had cut emissions by just 9.5 per cent from 2005 levels. Under the Paris Agreement, it has pledged to reduce them by 40 to 45 per cent. Current policies show that the country may not reach that target until 2050, the institute says. 

Arthur Zhang, a senior research associate with the institute’s 4440 Megatonnes project, said that emissions have largely stagnated. He pointed to changes to industrial carbon pricing, the cancellation of the federal electric vehicle sales mandate and uncertainty around clean electricity regulation as setbacks.

“We could probably pull a little bit more weight in order for us to be called a climate leader,” Zhang said. 

Canada ranked 61 out of 76 countries in the 2026 Climate Change Performance Index, receiving a “very low” rating for emissions, renewable energy and energy use. 

Bipasha Baruah, a research chair and professor at Western University said that climate leadership means “walking the talk.” She questioned how much real work happens at COP meetings, describing them as increasingly focused on publicity and political positioning rather than making actual commitments. 

Baruah acknowledged Canada’s international climate financing and clean electricity investments, but she questioned how those commitments align with continued support for fossil fuel development. 

“The Stone Age didn’t end because we ran out of stones,” she said. “It ended because we figured out better ways of making tools.”

That tension extends beyond emissions targets. In an emailed statement, Carole Monture, Education and Training Manager of Indigenous Climate Action, said Indigenous communities are leading renewable energy work but are not meaningfully included in major energy decisions. 

“Our inherent, distinct, and collective rights are being steamrolled in the name of ‘energy sovereignty’ and major projects,” Monture wrote. 

At COP31, Canada is asking the world to believe climate action and economic growth can move forward together, while Carney received the satirical “Fossil of the Day” award from Climate Action Network International, given to countries who are believed to be hindering climate progress.

Robinson said she struggles to understand why the government is not taking greater responsibility for climate change, an issue she believes requires countries to work together. 

“We learn as children about sharing," she said. "We learn as children about doing our part … and we aren’t even seeing that basic understanding in our government."